Got a photo? Identify rocks instantly with the Rockby app
Open the appDescription
Iron concretions in shale are discrete, often spherical, ovoid, or irregularly shaped masses of iron-rich minerals that have grown within a shale host rock. They are typically harder and denser than the surrounding shale, making them resistant to weathering and often found as lag deposits. Their internal structure can be massive, concentric, or septarian (cracked internally with mineral infillings). The primary iron minerals can include goethite, limonite (a mixture of iron oxyhydroxides), hematite, and siderite, often mixed with clay minerals, quartz, and organic matter from the host shale.
How to Identify
- Color
- Typically reddish-brown, yellowish-brown, dark brown, or black due to various iron oxides/hydroxides. Can be grey to brownish-grey if siderite is dominant and unweathered.
- Luster
- Dull to earthy, sometimes sub-metallic if hematite is prominent.
- Texture
- Fine-grained to cryptocrystalline, often massive. Can be granular or show concentric banding. The surface may be smooth or botryoidal. Often much harder and denser than the surrounding shale.
- Crystal Form
- Macroscopic crystal forms are rare; typically anhedral aggregates forming nodular or discoidal masses. Septarian concretions show internal cracks filled with secondary minerals (e.g., calcite, quartz, barite).
- Cleavage
- No distinct cleavage in the concretionary mass itself, though individual mineral components may have cleavage (e.g., siderite).
- Geological Environment
- Found embedded within fine-grained sedimentary rocks, predominantly shales, mudstones, and siltstones. They are common in marine and lacustrine environments where anoxic conditions can lead to iron mobilization and subsequent precipitation.
Key Facts
- Hardness: Variable, typically 3.5 to 6.5 on the Mohs scale, depending on the dominant iron mineral (e.g., siderite ~3.5-4.5, goethite ~5-5.5, hematite ~5.5-6.5). Generally harder than the host shale.
- Specific Gravity: Variable, typically 2.9 to 4.5, depending on mineral composition. Significantly denser than typical shale (2.0-2.8).
- Crystal System: Individual mineral components have their own crystal systems (e.g., siderite: trigonal; goethite: orthorhombic; hematite: trigonal). The concretion as a whole is an aggregate and does not have a single crystal system.
- Color: Reddish-brown, yellowish-brown, dark brown, black, or greyish-brown.
- Luster: Dull, earthy, sometimes sub-metallic.
- Transparency: Opaque.
- Fracture: Uneven to conchoidal, sometimes splintery.
- Cleavage: None for the concretionary mass; individual mineral components may exhibit cleavage (e.g., siderite has perfect rhombohedral cleavage).
- Composition: Primarily iron oxides (e.g., goethite, hematite), iron hydroxides (e.g., limonite), and/or iron carbonates (e.g., siderite), mixed with varying amounts of clay minerals, quartz, and organic matter from the host shale.
Quick Check
- Color: Reddish-brown, yellowish-brown, dark brown, black, or greyish-brown.
- Luster: Dull to earthy, sometimes sub-metallic.
- Streak: Yellowish-brown, reddish-brown, or black (depending on the dominant iron mineral).
Physical Characteristics
- Crystal Habit: Nodular, discoidal, spherical, ovoid, or irregular masses; often massive or concentrically banded. Septarian concretions show internal polygonal cracks.
- Cleavage Type: Not applicable to the concretion as a whole. Individual mineral components may have cleavage (e.g., siderite: perfect rhombohedral).
- Fracture Type: Uneven, conchoidal, or splintery.
- Tenacity: Brittle.
- Luster Type: Dull, earthy, sub-metallic.
Formation
Iron concretions form within shale layers through the precipitation of iron-bearing minerals (primarily iron oxides, hydroxides, and carbonates) from circulating groundwater or pore fluids. This precipitation is often initiated around a nucleus (e.g., a fossil fragment, a grain of sand, or organic matter) and grows outwards, displacing or incorporating the surrounding shale matrix. The process is diagenetic, occurring after the initial deposition of the shale but before full lithification. Redox conditions play a crucial role, with iron typically mobilized in reducing environments and precipitated in oxidizing zones or where pH changes occur.
Usage
Historically, large ironstone concretions, particularly those rich in siderite or hematite, were mined as low-grade iron ore (e.g., 'clay ironstone' in the Carboniferous coal measures). Today, they are primarily of scientific interest for paleontological studies (as they often preserve fossils), sedimentological research (indicating diagenetic processes and fluid flow), and as geological curiosities for collectors. They have limited industrial use due to their variable composition and often small size.
Age Distribution
Commonly found in sedimentary rocks of various ages, from Precambrian to Cenozoic, wherever iron-rich fluids and suitable host sediments (shale) were present.
Where to Find
Ohio, USA
Famous for ironstone concretions, particularly in the Pennsylvanian-age shales of the Appalachian Basin, often containing well-preserved fossils (e.g., Mazon Creek-type concretions).
Illinois, USA
The Francis Creek Shale Member of the Carbondale Formation (Pennsylvanian) is renowned for its ironstone concretions containing exceptional soft-bodied fossils (Mazon Creek biota).
United Kingdom
Common in Carboniferous coal measures (e.g., 'clay ironstone' in shales associated with coal seams) and Jurassic shales (e.g., Cleveland Ironstone Formation).
Germany
Found in various Mesozoic and Cenozoic sedimentary basins, often associated with marine shales.
Canada
Present in shales of various ages, including Cretaceous shales of the Western Canada Sedimentary Basin.
Finding Tips
Look for Resistant Masses
Concretions are typically harder and more resistant to weathering than the surrounding shale. Look for rounded or irregular lumps protruding from weathered shale outcrops, or as loose, dense masses in stream beds and eroded slopes where the softer shale has been removed.
Examine Shale Outcrops
Carefully inspect exposed shale layers. Concretions often occur in distinct horizons or layers within the shale. Freshly exposed shale may reveal concretions still partially embedded.
Check for Fossil Associations
Many iron concretions form around organic nuclei, including fossils. Breaking open concretions (carefully, with appropriate safety gear) can sometimes reveal well-preserved plant or animal fossils within. This is particularly true for septarian concretions.
Observe Color and Density
Iron concretions will generally be darker (reddish-brown, black) and noticeably denser than the surrounding grey or black shale. A simple 'heft test' can often distinguish them.
Similar Rocks
Manganese Concretion
Manganese oxide/hydroxide concretion
Also known as: Manganese Nodule
Calcite Concretion
Calcium carbonate concretion
Also known as: Limestone Concretion
Pyrite Concretion
Iron sulfide concretion
Also known as: Iron Pyrite Nodule
Chert Nodule
Silica concretion
Also known as: Flint Nodule
Scientific Classification
- Mineral Class
- Oxides, Hydroxides, or Carbonates (depending on dominant mineral)
- Group
- Concretion (a secondary sedimentary structure, not a mineral group)
- Crystal System
- Not applicable to the concretion as a whole; individual minerals have their own systems.
- Chemical Formula
- Variable, e.g., FeO(OH) (goethite), Fe2O3 (hematite), FeCO3 (siderite), often mixed with silicates and other impurities.
- Composition
- Mixture of iron-bearing minerals (goethite, limonite, hematite, siderite) and detrital/authigenic components from the host shale (clay minerals, quartz, organic matter).
Explore Iron Concretion in Shale
Identify rocks anywhere
Free on iOS, Android, and Web. Photo identification, full database, and your personal collection.