Botryoidal Smithsonite on Limonite

Mineral Aggregate

ZnCO3 on FeO(OH)

Also known as: Zinc Spar (for Smithsonite), Brown Iron Ore (for Limonite)

Got a photo? Identify rocks instantly with the Rockby app

Description

This specimen consists of botryoidal (grape-like or mammillary) aggregates of smithsonite, typically forming crusts or layers, deposited on a substrate of limonite. Smithsonite, a zinc carbonate, often exhibits a range of colors due to trace impurities, including blue, green, yellow, pink, and white, though it can be colorless. Its botryoidal habit is characteristic, presenting as rounded, globular masses. Limonite, a hydrated iron oxide, serves as the matrix and is typically earthy, porous, and ranges in color from yellow-brown to dark brown or black. The contrast in color and texture between the often vibrant smithsonite and the dull, earthy limonite creates aesthetically pleasing specimens.

How to Identify

Color: Smithsonite: Variable, commonly blue, green, yellow, pink, white, gray, or colorless. Limonite: Yellow-brown, brown, dark brown, black.
Luster: Smithsonite: Vitreous to sub-vitreous, pearly on cleavage surfaces. Limonite: Dull, earthy, sometimes submetallic.
Texture: Smithsonite: Botryoidal, mammillary, reniform, stalactitic, granular, massive. Limonite: Earthy, porous, massive, stalactitic, concretionary.
Crystal Form: Smithsonite: Typically botryoidal aggregates, also rhombohedral crystals (rarely), massive. Limonite: Amorphous to cryptocrystalline, massive, concretionary, stalactitic.
Cleavage: Smithsonite: Perfect rhombohedral {1011}. Limonite: None (amorphous/cryptocrystalline).
Geological Environment: Oxidized zones of zinc-bearing sulfide deposits, often in carbonate host rocks. Associated with other secondary minerals like hemimorphite, cerussite, anglesite, malachite, azurite, and various iron oxides/hydroxides.

Key Facts

Hardness: Smithsonite: 4-4.5 (Mohs). Limonite: 4-5.5 (variable due to amorphous nature).
Specific Gravity: Smithsonite: 4.30-4.45. Limonite: 2.7-4.3 (variable).
Crystal System: Smithsonite: Trigonal. Limonite: Amorphous to cryptocrystalline (no defined crystal system).
Color: Smithsonite: Blue, green, yellow, pink, white, gray, colorless. Limonite: Yellow-brown, brown, dark brown, black.
Luster: Smithsonite: Vitreous to sub-vitreous, pearly. Limonite: Dull, earthy, sometimes submetallic.
Transparency: Smithsonite: Transparent to translucent. Limonite: Opaque.
Fracture: Smithsonite: Uneven to subconchoidal. Limonite: Uneven, earthy.
Cleavage: Smithsonite: Perfect rhombohedral {1011}. Limonite: None.
Composition: Smithsonite: Zinc Carbonate (ZnCO3). Limonite: Hydrated Iron Oxide-Hydroxide (FeO(OH)·nH2O).

Quick Check

Color: Smithsonite: Varied (blue, green, yellow, white, etc.). Limonite: Brown to yellow-brown.
Luster: Smithsonite: Vitreous to pearly. Limonite: Dull, earthy.
Streak: Smithsonite: White. Limonite: Yellow-brown.

Physical Characteristics

Crystal Habit: Smithsonite: Botryoidal, mammillary, reniform, stalactitic, granular, massive, rarely rhombohedral crystals. Limonite: Massive, earthy, concretionary, stalactitic, mammillary.
Cleavage Type: Smithsonite: Perfect rhombohedral {1011}. Limonite: None.
Fracture Type: Smithsonite: Uneven to subconchoidal. Limonite: Uneven, earthy.
Tenacity: Smithsonite: Brittle. Limonite: Brittle to friable.
Luster Type: Smithsonite: Vitreous to sub-vitreous, pearly on cleavage. Limonite: Dull, earthy, sometimes submetallic.

Formation

Smithsonite forms as a secondary mineral in the oxidized zone of zinc-bearing ore deposits. It typically precipitates from circulating groundwater that has dissolved zinc from primary sulfide minerals (like sphalerite, ZnS) and reacted with carbonate-rich host rocks or dissolved CO2. Limonite, a general term for amorphous or cryptocrystalline hydrated iron oxides, forms through the oxidation of primary iron-bearing minerals (e.g., pyrite, FeS2) in the presence of water and oxygen. The botryoidal habit of smithsonite indicates formation in open spaces where crystals grew outward from a central point, often in colloform layers. The association with limonite suggests a common supergene environment where both zinc and iron were mobilized and redeposited.

Usage

Smithsonite is an ore of zinc, though less significant than sphalerite. High-quality botryoidal specimens are highly prized by mineral collectors. Limonite itself is a minor iron ore and has been used as a pigment (ochre).

Age Distribution

Secondary minerals formed in the supergene zone, thus their age is typically much younger than the primary ore deposits from which they derive, often Cenozoic to recent.

Where to Find

Kelly Mine, Magdalena, New Mexico, USA

Famous for its vibrant blue and green botryoidal smithsonite, often found on limonite or other iron oxides.

Tsumeb Mine, Tsumeb, Namibia

Known for a wide variety of secondary minerals, including excellent smithsonite specimens in various colors, sometimes on limonite.

Choix, Sinaloa, Mexico

Produces fine botryoidal smithsonite, including blue and green varieties, often associated with iron oxides.

Lavrion (Laurium) Mines, Attica, Greece

Historic mining district with numerous secondary minerals, including smithsonite and limonite.

Broken Hill, New South Wales, Australia

Significant lead-zinc-silver deposit with a rich oxidized zone producing various secondary minerals, including smithsonite.

Finding Tips

Target Oxidized Zones

Focus on the upper, weathered portions of zinc-lead sulfide deposits, where primary sulfides have been altered by groundwater and oxygen.

Look for Carbonate Host Rocks

Smithsonite formation is favored in the presence of carbonate rocks (limestone, dolomite) which provide the carbonate ions for its precipitation.

Identify Iron Staining

Limonite is a common indicator of oxidized sulfide deposits. Look for brown, yellow, or reddish staining on rocks, which may indicate the presence of iron oxides and potentially associated smithsonite.

Check for Botryoidal Forms

The characteristic 'grape-like' or 'bubbly' texture of botryoidal smithsonite is a key visual identifier.

Perform Acid Test (Carefully)

Smithsonite (ZnCO3) will effervesce (fizz) in dilute hydrochloric acid, though often slowly unless powdered. Limonite will not react. Always use caution with acids and wear appropriate safety gear.

Similar Rocks

Hemimorphite on Limonite

Hemimorphite (Zn4Si2O7(OH)2·H2O) on Limonite (FeO(OH)·nH2O)

Also known as: Calamine (historical, often confused with smithsonite)

Malachite on Limonite

Malachite (Cu2(CO3)(OH)2) on Limonite (FeO(OH)·nH2O)

Also known as: Copper Carbonate

Aurichalcite on Limonite

Aurichalcite ((Zn,Cu)5(CO3)2(OH)6) on Limonite (FeO(OH)·nH2O)

Also known as: Zinc-Copper Carbonate Hydroxide

Scientific Classification

Mineral Class: Smithsonite: Carbonates. Limonite: Hydroxides (often considered a rock rather than a distinct mineral species due to its variable composition and amorphous nature, but mineralogically falls under hydroxides).
Group: Smithsonite: Calcite Group. Limonite: Iron Hydroxides.
Crystal System: Smithsonite: Trigonal. Limonite: Amorphous to cryptocrystalline.
Chemical Formula: Smithsonite: ZnCO3. Limonite: FeO(OH)·nH2O (approximate, as it's a mixture).
Composition: Smithsonite: Zinc carbonate. Limonite: Hydrated iron oxide-hydroxide.

Explore Botryoidal Smithsonite on Limonite

Identification Localities & Collecting Look-alikes

Identify rocks anywhere

Free on iOS, Android, and Web. Photo identification, full database, and your personal collection.

Download on theApp Store Get it onGoogle Play Continue onWeb

Open in app